Pensions vs. ISAs - finding the right balance for retirement

Planning for retirement requires careful consideration of the best savings vehicles available, and two of the most popular options in the UK are pensions and ISAs (Individual Savings Accounts). While both offer tax-efficient ways to grow wealth, they serve different purposes and come with distinct advantages and limitations. A well-rounded retirement strategy may involve using both, depending on individual financial goals, tax considerations, and evolving regulations.

Arrange your free initial consultation

The Role of Pensions in retirement planning

Pensions are designed primarily for long-term retirement savings, offering significant tax advantages that make them an attractive option. One of the biggest benefits is the tax relief on contributions—money paid into a pension receives tax relief at an individual’s marginal tax rate, effectively reducing the amount of tax paid on earnings. For higher or additional-rate taxpayers, this makes pensions particularly valuable, as contributions can benefit from 40% or even 45% tax relief, depending on income levels.

Additionally, pensions provide tax-free investment growth, allowing savings to accumulate over time without being eroded by capital gains tax or dividend tax. When it comes to withdrawing funds, 25% of a pension pot can be taken as a tax-free lump sum, while the remaining balance is subject to income tax. The trade-off for these benefits is that pension savings are locked in until at least age 55 (rising to 57 in 2028), making them less accessible in comparison to ISAs.

The flexibility of ISAs

ISAs, on the other hand, offer tax-free growth and withdrawals, making them an excellent complement to pensions in a retirement strategy. While contributions do not receive tax relief, the ability to access funds at any time without penalty makes ISAs more versatile. This flexibility can be particularly useful for those who may need to draw on savings before retirement or wish to supplement their pension income without triggering additional tax liabilities. ISAs have a limit of £20,000 per individual per tax year and this can be split across cash and/or stocks and shares.

Cash ISAs allow savers to earn tax-free interest, while Stocks & Shares ISAs provide the potential for investment growth with no capital gains or dividend tax on returns. This makes ISAs an attractive choice for those who want to retain control over their savings without the restrictions of a pension. However, recent discussions about potential changes to the Cash ISA framework have raised concerns about its long-term benefits, making it all the more important for savers to stay informed about policy updates.

The changing landscape of Pensions and Inheritance Tax

One of the most significant changes being proposed for pensions  is the planned inclusion of pension funds within the scope of inheritance tax (IHT) from 2027. Historically, pensions have been an efficient way to pass wealth down to future generations, as they have typically fallen outside of an individual’s estate for IHT purposes. This has led many financial advisers to recommend using non-pension savings first in retirement, preserving pension wealth to be inherited tax-free.

However, with the proposed new rule changes, pensions may no longer enjoy this exemption, potentially making them less favourable for wealth transfer. This shift may encourage retirees to draw down on their pensions earlier rather than leaving them untouched, making strategic planning even more essential. Individuals should review their estate planning strategies in light of these proposed changes to ensure they optimise tax efficiency while securing their financial future.

Balancing Pensions and ISAs for a stronger retirement plan

Given the unique advantages of both pensions and ISAs, a balanced approach can help individuals make the most of their retirement savings. Pensions remain a powerful tool for long-term wealth accumulation due to tax relief and employer contributions, but they have some limitations on access and flexibility and could soon be subject to inheritance tax. ISAs, while not offering tax relief on contributions, provide tax-free growth and withdrawals, making them an excellent complement for early or flexible access to savings – but are limited to £20,000 contribution per tax year.

Younger savers may prioritise pensions to take full advantage of employer contributions and tax relief, ensuring they build a solid foundation for the future. Meanwhile, those approaching retirement may benefit from shifting some focus to ISAs, allowing for accessible savings that can be drawn upon without incurring additional tax burdens. Given the proposed changes to pension inheritance tax, retirees may also need to rethink how they draw down their savings, potentially using pensions earlier than previously advised.

With tax laws and regulations evolving, seeking professional financial advice is crucial to navigating the complexities of retirement planning. A tailored strategy that considers tax efficiency, investment growth, attitude to risk, and changing policies can make a significant difference in long-term financial security. By carefully balancing contributions between pensions and ISAs, individuals can build a more resilient retirement portfolio that aligns with their goals and adapts to the shifting financial landscape.

We’re currently offering anyone with £100,000 or more in pensions, savings or investments  a free initial financial review worth £500. If you’d like to learn more, get in touch for an initial consultation to see how we can help.

Arrange your free initial consultation

This article is intended for general information only, it does not constitute individual advice and should not be used to inform financial decisions. 

The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) does not regulate tax planning.

Investment returns are not guaranteed, and you may get back less than you originally invested. Past performance is not a guide to future returns.

The information contained within this article is based on our understanding of legislation, whether proposed or in force, and market practice at the time of writing. Levels, bases and reliefs from taxation may be subject to change.